Friday, July 31, 2009

Court Refuses to Vacate Markman Ruling Following Settlement


In the case Unigen Pharmaceuticals v. Walgreen Co. (07-471 RAJ), which is actually a consolidation of three cases brought by plaintiff Unigen, asserting infringement of US Patent No. 7,192,611 (for more on the consolidation, click here), the parties recently settled and approached the court jointly to dismiss the case and to also vacate a prior claims construction ruling.

The claims of the '611 patent are directed to a method for treating osteoarthritis using what is known as a Free-B-Ring flavonoid, which includes baicalein. The three defendants are Walgreens, Target, and Perrigo Company of South Carolina Inc. On March 18, 2009, Judge Jones construed the claims of the '611 to require inter alia: "that the patient recognize that he has a 'COX-2 and 5-LO mediated inflammatory condition' and to take the claimed composition for treating that condition by direct inhibition of COX-2 and 5-LO." This effectively required that the "Host Must Intend to Take the Extracts to Treat a Condition as Described in the Preamble." In other words, just proving that the extracts were taken, and that they exhibited the function as claimed, was not enough to show direct infringement. The court further concluded that "each of the preambles of the disputed claims contains a limitation restricting the claimed method to enzyme inhibition of an enzyme mediated disease (e.g., osteoarthritis in ‘611 Claims 1 and 8), condition (e.g., inflammatory condition in ‘868 Claims 1 and 4), or physical limitation (e.g., limited physical function, flexibility, and mobility in ‘611 Claim 15)."

In his order refusing to vacate the Markman ruling, Judge Jones concluded as follows:

Despite begin unable to point out why vacatur would be valuable, the parties want it. It would be more accurate, of course, to say that Plaintiff wants it. No Defendant has any stake in the order being vacated, as they are no doubt shielded from future litigation over the patents-in-suit by virtue of their settlement with Plaintiff. There is something (or perhaps many somethings) in the claim construction order that Plaintiff does not like, and vacating it is apparently preferable to Plaintiff. But again, the court has no idea what underlies Plaintiff’s belief. Whether the court vacates the order or not, it remains in the public record, and has as much persuasive effect as any court or party wishes to accord it. Vacatur does not make an order disappear. See Cisco, 590 F. Supp. 2d at 831 (“[The claim construction order] is now on the internet, available to anyone with a computer.”). If vacating the claim construction order is a nugatory act, then the court declines to take it if for no other reason than it does not wish to encourage parties to file motions requesting that the court issue meaningless orders.

If, on the other hand, vacating the claim construction order has some impact, either in terms of the slight possibility that a court will give it preclusive effect, or in terms of its value as a persuasive precedent, the equities counsel against vacating it. Only Plaintiff has an interest in vacating the order, whereas a larger set of potentially interested third parties has an interest in it as a precedent. The court’s orders “are not merely the property of private litigants and should stand unless a court concludes that the public interest would be served by a vacatur.” United States Bancorp Mortg. Co. v. Bonner Mall P'ship, 513 U.S. 18, 26 (1994) (quoting Izumi Seimitsu Kogyo Kabushiki Kaisha v. U.S. Philips Corp., 510 U.S. 27, 40 (1993)). Because “[j]udicial precedents are presumptively correct and valuable to the legal community as a whole,” id., vacating them in the service of a single litigant is generally inadvisable.

Moreover, the court cannot overlook the investment of judicial (and thus public) resources in the claim construction order. See, e.g., Tumulty v. FedEx Ground Package Sys., Inc., No. C04-1425P, 2007 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 20429 (W.D. Wash. Mar. 22, 2007) (declining to impliedly undo decision reached after intensive litigation by vacating judgment). Patent cases, perhaps more than any other genre of litigation, strain the resources of district courts. The claim construction process in particular is burdensome, as the parties almost invariably flood the court with lengthy briefs and exhibits, and the court’s analysis of disputed claim terms is labor-intensive, to say the least. In this case, the court reviewed the parties’ voluminous claim construction materials, held a Markman hearing, and issued a lengthy (by this court’s standards) claim construction order. In doing so, it diverted focus from hundreds of other cases on its docket. Vacating a claim construction order deprives the public of whatever benefit inures from the court’s investment in resolving patent cases. Zinus, Inc. v. Simmons Bedding Co., No. C 07-3012PVT, 2008 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 33359, at *3-6 (N. D. Cal. Apr. 23, 2008) (declining to vacate claim construction order). As the Zinus court bluntly put it: The public paid for this use of court resources through its tax dollars. Vacatur would render that expenditure a waste, and the parties cite no public interest that would be served by vacatur which would justify the waste of public funds.
Id. at *6.

Finally, the court’s declining to vacate its order will not discourage settlement. It will not discourage settlement in this case because the parties’ settlement is not conditioned on vacatur. As to other litigants, vacating the claim construction order would set a dangerous precedent. This court is not a place for a patent holder to “test drive” its patent. A patent holder who asserts its patent and proceeds to claim construction must be prepared for the possibility of an unfavorable construction, and must not believe that vacatur will serve as its get-out-of-jail-free card. Otherwise, there is nothing to discourage a patent holder from refusing to settle questionable patent claims prior to the expensive claim construction process. Id. at *5 (citing United States Bancorp, 513 U.S. at 28). Indeed, in this case, the parties filed numerous motions before claim construction, leading to several other interlocutory orders. The prospect of a claim construction that will not be erased at the request of the parties can only discourage unnecessary litigation.

For all of these reasons, the court finds that the equities weigh against vacating its claim construction order. The court therefore DENIES the parties’ motion to vacate


Unigen%20Motion%20to%20Vacate%20Markman%20Ruling.pdfUnigen%20Order%20Denying%20M%20Vacate%20Markman.pdf

Labels: , , , ,

Wednesday, April 30, 2008

New Study Says Western District's Claim Construction Decisions Get Reversed Nearly 40% of the Time

A soon-to-be-published study in the Michigan Law Review says that claim construction decisions by the Western District of Washington were reversed by the CAFC 38.9 % of the time during the time period April 24, 1996 (the date of the Supreme Court's decision in Markman) and June 30, 2007. Presented by Professor David L. Schwartz, the study seeks to test the conventional wisdom that "[p]ractice makes perfect - the old adage promises that the more you practice, the better you will become." The theory here is that the busiest judicial districts for patent litigation (the Western District of Washington is ranked 14th in terms of the number of claim construction decisions appealed to the CAFC during this time period) ought to fare better over time in terms of claim construction reversal rate. The results of Schwartz' study may surprise you (or perhaps not). His study shows that the level of judicial experience with claims construction issues appears to have little, if any, impact on reversal rate. Nor does reversal rate decrease when a district court judge has more CAFC appeals. Indeed the busiest judicial district during this time period (measured either in terms of the number of appeals or the number of patent cases filed), the C.D. of California, had the highest reversal rate of any of the "busy" judicial districts for patent litigation, with 43.5% of all claim construction decisions reversed by the CAFC. In short, practice does not make perfect when it comes to issues of claims construction.

Why is this the case? Why doesn't "practice make perfect" in the realm of claim construction? The primary culprit according to Schwartz is that "[c]laim construction may be inherently indeterminate." You think? Do you mean to say there are multiple, potentially outcome-changing ways to interpret claim language? Forgive the sarcasm, but anyone who has litigated a patent case knows that claim construction in many cases is a crap shoot. It comes down to good advocacy and this why it is so important to choose your counsel wisely.

NOTE: This post was updated May 10, 2008 to reflect the fact that the study is not yet published and to provide an updated link.

Labels: , , , , ,

Tuesday, January 15, 2008

Wacom Loses Request for Reconsideration of Claims Construction Order

I posted here about the claims construction order issued by Judge Bryan in the Wacom v. Hanvon litigation. This case involves several patents covering electronic pen and tablet technology. Wacom had moved for reconsideration of the Judge Bryan's claims construction order arguing manifest and "pervasive" errors of law. In essence, Wacom asserted that the order erroneously "put the patent invalidity cart before the claim construction horse" by construing the claims to "preserve their validity." Judge Bryan denied the motion.

From Judge Bryan's Order:

"Plaintiffs argue that the Court made manifest and pervasive errors of law by requiring Plaintiffs to prove that their proposed constructions for multiple means-plus-function claims were valid. Dkt. 113 at 4-5. Plaintiffs assert “that the ‘doctrine of construing claims to preserve their validity . . . has no applicability’ except where the claim is ambiguous even after applying all of the tools of claim construction.” Dkt. 113 at 4 citing Phillips v. AWH Corp., 415 F.3d 1303, 1327-8 (Fed. Cir. 2005). However, “[t]he applicability of the doctrine [of construing claims to preserve their validity] in a particular case therefore depends on the strength of the inference that the [Patent and Trademark Office (“PTO”)] would have recognized that one claim interpretation would render the claim invalid, and that the PTO would not have issued the patent assuming that to be the proper construction of the term.” Id. at 1328. For the ‘553 Patent, Plaintiffs’ proposed means-plus-function constructions were so limited, vague, and
unsupported by the weight of intrinsic and extrinsic evidence in the record that a brief discussion of invalidity was required. Moreover, Plaintiffs were consistent in advancing the same limited arguments and unsupported constructions for the means-plus-functions limitations in the remainder of the asserted patents."


WacomOrderDenyingReconsideration.pdf

Labels: , , , , ,

Thursday, January 3, 2008

Wacom Cries Foul Over Recent Claim Construction Order



Japanese manufacturer of pen and tablet components, Wacom Technology Corporation, alleged Patent Infringement, Violation of 35 U.S.C. § 292, and Unfair Competition, by Defendant Hanvon Corporation . There are six U.S. Patents involved in this case: RE34,187; 4,878,553 (as reexamined), 4,999,461, 5,134,689, RE35,329, and 5,691,513. All patents relate to pen and tablet products and related components. In a claims construction order issued by Judge Bryan on December 21, 2007, 46 separate claim terms were constructed. Judge Bryan's order provides some important insights and practice tips for those litigating patent cases in his court. From the order: "While the majority of the technology involved in this case is governed by Faraday’s Law of Induction (footnote omitted), the claim constructions should be governed by Ockham’s Razor (footnote omitted), which states that one should not increase, beyond what is necessary, the complexity required to explain anything. In other words, the public notice function of patent law is best served if these patents stand on their own two feet without the supporting crutch of complicated judicial constructions."




Judge Bryan's 34-page claims construction order and his 17-page claims construction chart are attached below. Wacom asked for reconsideration in a motion filed on New Year's Eve, 2007. Wacom's primary argument for reconsideration rests on an alleged "manifest and pervasive error of law" tainting the construction of 15 claim terms. According to Wacom's motion, the order mistakenly "conflates claim construction with patent validity—two entirely different exercises in patent law." In essence, Wacom argues that Federal Circuit law prohibits courts from re-writing claim terms under the guise of "preserving validity" and that this improperly places the burden on the patent holder to prove validity at the claims construction phase. The motion for reconsideration is also attached below.

WacomClaimsConstruction.pdf
WacomClaimsConstOrderChart.pdf
WacomMotionforReconsideration.pdf

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Monday, December 10, 2007

Microsoft and Nintendo Battle Game Controller Patents In ED of Texas

A recent claim construction ruling in a case involving both Nintendo and Microsoft set the stage for a Spring 2008 jury trial on a number of patents involving game controller technology owned by Plaintiff Anascape Ltd. Both Microsoft and Nintendo sought unsuccessfully to stay the entire litigation in view of an on-going reexamination of several patents-in-suit. Judge Ron Clark stayed the litigation as to some but not all of the patents. In his claims construction order, entered November 30, 2007, Judge Carter construed seven terms that relate to four patents, Patent Nos. 5,999,084, 6,102,802, 6,135,886, and 6,343,991. These patents all relate to the switches and buttons on controllers used for video games. The Order (link below PDF), awarded Anascape its definition for “pressure-sensitive variable conductance material,” finding that Microsoft's construction improperly tried to limit the definition of the disputed claim term by excluding a preferred embodiment of the term. He also agreed with Anascape's contention that no construction was necessary for terms related to individual button pressing. Anascape lost any literal infringement arguments concerning the terms “pressure-sensitive variable conductance material” and “means for creating an analog [output proportional to][signal representing] varying applied physical pressure.” According to Judge Carter, the jury will have to pass on these limitations under a theory of infringement by the Doctrine of Equivalents.

In large part, the claims construction order seemed to give Anascape what it wanted, however, Anascape just asked the Court to continue its trial date because of certain scheduling conflicts of its lead trial lawyers, McKool Smith.
AnscapeClaimsConstruction.pdf
AnscapevMSFTNoticeofClaimrejections.pdf
AnscapevMSFTPTOOrderReexam.htm
AnascapevMSFTNoticeofreexam.htm

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,